Order Online

Call us @

608-839-3102


Pizza & Calzone
Jimmy's Munchies
Pasta
Subs
Salads
Beverages
Ice Cream
Full Menu
       


Pint

Pint

$6.25
Quart

Quart

$11.50

Kids, Single, Double, Triple
Kids Dish/Sugar or Wafer Cone

Kids Dish/Sugar or Wafer Cone

$3.30
Single Dish/Sugar or Wafer Cone

Single Dish/Sugar or Wafer Cone

$3.90
Double Dish/Sugar or Wafer Cone

Double Dish/Sugar or Wafer Cone

$4.99
Triple Dish/Sugar or Wafer Cone

Triple Dish/Sugar or Wafer Cone

$6.09
Single Waffle Cone

Single Waffle Cone

$4.49
Double Waffle Cone

Double Waffle Cone

$5.49

Cookie Sandwich

$3.98
Chocolate Chip Cookie

Chocolate Chip Cookie

$0.59
3 Chocolate Chip Cookies Special

3 Chocolate Chip Cookies Special

$1.50

Chocolate, Vanilla, Specialty, Strawberry

Shakes & Malts

Regular - $5.21
Extra Thick - $5.71
Specialty Shake

Specialty Shake

What makes it a specialty? Making a shake with any ice cream other than vanilla or chocolate.

$5.40

Twister

$5.71

Root Beer Float

$3.98

Hot Fudge, Turtle, Caramel

Small Hot Fudge/Caramel

$3.98

Large Hot Fudge/Caramel

$4.98

Small Turtle

$4.50

Large Turtle

$5.50

YEAR ROUND: Cotton Candy, Turtle, Vanilla, Chocolate, Ultimate Oreo, Butter Pecan, Cookie Dough, Blue Moon, Heaps Of Love, Peanut Butter Cup, Mint Avalanche, Coconut Almond Bliss, Peanut Butter Cookie Dough, Zoreo, Zanzibar
SEASONAL: Raspberry Rhapsody, This Just Got Serious, Kitty Kitty Bang Bang, Superman, Munchie Madness, Fat Elvis, Eggnog, Lemon Meringue
COFFEE FLAVORS: Expresso Oreo, Exhausted Parent, Cappuccino Break

Brownies, Oreos, Reeses Peanut Butter Cup, M&Ms, Take 5


Copyright 2007-2023 Papa Jimmy's Pizzeria
224 W. Cottage Grove Rd
Cottage Grove, WI 53527